My first solo attempt at this dessert masterpiece was as a newly-wed wishing to impress my husband & family for his birthday. The cake was a triumph; alas, the frosting was not. It looked something like this:
When I first went gluten free, I made these Red Velvet cupcakes. But, I’ve been craving the flavor of Aunt Ruth’s authentic recipe; so when Kristen announced that October’s Improv Challenge would be CAKE & FROSTING, I knew I had to challenge myself to make a genuine Red Velvet tastefully gluten free. (I am not going to go off on the ubiquitous boxedmixwannaberedvelvetsomethingfrostedwithcreamcheeseicing…)
First thing I did was to call my cousin and beg for pictures of her mom’s recipe card. (So love seeing Aunt Ruth’s writing in green felt-tip pen. Can you tell she was a teacher?)
Next I did a bunch of research on flours, their weight and protein content. I detailed that thought-process in a blog post here: (well… it will be as soon as I finish it…)
¡voilà! My recipe for you:data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d0923/d0923a27baed9f77128d236b5c7299ee2214955a" alt="ejRVrecipe ejRVrecipe"
(I realize the format looks a little strange, but it helps me see how the individual steps work together.)data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/59922/5992287fe9d4f43b47ba1138e461c3897a84b05f" alt="DSCN8740 DSCN8740"
Rounded up the ingredients, then prepped my pans…
So thankful to have Colby (our cobalt KitchenAid) fully functional thanks to my resourceful daddy. This recipe would’ve been difficult to manage “by hand”.data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/df38d/df38da0469cb59085427ba763d2248295a327c75" alt="DSCN8745 DSCN8745"
After the initial “wet” ingredients were mixed, I weighed my flours.data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1d5b5/1d5b596be95875f8247dd8986e1c07169bc9d340" alt="DSCN8746 DSCN8746"
The batter was a little thick going into the pan…data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/fc6c5/fc6c5c9b83108b6942a99fb04f8eaf0e4c155b4d" alt="DSCN8747 DSCN8747"
but baked with a decent rise.data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/898ab/898abd5de018103496e8a0bda169eb586363460d" alt="DSCN8749 DSCN8749"
Frosting attempt was next.data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4ebd0/4ebd027e01b1beb7a5eae3af17157da928b64414" alt="DSCN8753 DSCN8753"
Here’s my obligatory steam shot.data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/91128/91128b7636ac6b5b307444d24a4b1e0a70949ffc" alt="Smile"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8c248/8c24845dcf8fb95fda36aaa0c1855e8c2671aab7" alt="DSCN8754 DSCN8754"
The rice flour thickened the milk quickly.data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3f888/3f8880c89e33c1ac7a8cb70274c464107c021871" alt="DSCN8755 DSCN8755"
I managed to split the layers, but could tell I was going to have to work around a lot of crumbs.data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1041f/1041f9e9e7cc9dd36faaa6ac09640572afd4f621" alt="DSCN8756 DSCN8756"
Took me so long to frost that the butter started melting.data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2f23c/2f23c9f4034818d82fdae815ef4b208a99ae9f51" alt="DSCN8757 DSCN8757"
Glamor shot:data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ac882/ac88231c8464c7feea7acd7d25fcae11d9bde905" alt="DSCN8769 DSCN8769"
Aside from the frosting looking slightly lumpy (it actually felt fairly smooth in the mouth...) I was pretty pleased with my final product.data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1e46e/1e46e9fb3aefa63695963db56ba83ea6cb384674" alt="DSCN8771 DSCN8771"
…except for the taste. My guys all loved it (but they’d never had a chance to sample Aunt Ruth’s stellar cake). There was just something lacking for me in the flavor department.
So I baked another one this morning. I decided to ditch the brown rice flour and use more of the sorghum, some tapioca starch plus a little potato flour.
The texture seemed right & the batter tasted pretty good; but the cakes didn’t have much rise.
My Improv Challenge companions would love it if you would check out their cake & frosting links here: